Jump To Navigation

September 2011 Archives

Homeowners Sue City for Mudslide Damage

A recent mudslide that threatens the safety of six San Clemente homes had led to the filing of a lawsuit against the City of San Clemente. The homeowners blame a faulty water management plan of the city for imperiling their homes. The claim of the homeowners rests on the City's decision to dump storm water from an underground vault onto to slopes aready weakened from heavy storms. San Clemente City officials denied that their actions had any impact on the recent slope collapse near Via Ballena. Four homes on Via Ballena were recently red tagged by the City, indicating that they are not safe to be inhabited. Two other homes on the street are being monitored by the City, and may eventually be red tagged depending on further developments.

Understanding Common Soil Movement Problems, Part 1:

Real estate in Southern California is a valuable commodity. Even after the housing bust, the value of land in the southland far exceeds most areas of the country and world. Since most of the easy land has already been built on, Developer's are forced to build their product in areas that may cause problems after homes are constructed. Two common problems that cause soils movement are subsidence of soil or the expansion of soil under a building. Understanding these terms are the basis to understanding soil movement problems.SUBSIDENCE:
Construction of buildings frequently involves grading, which is essentially done to create a level building pad. If the natural ground has a slope, grading might be performed by cutting into the slope and partially removing it. Alternatively, additional soils can be brought to the building site to build up the pad elevation at the low lying areas. Soil that is not natural to the building area, but that is used to raise an existing grade is called fill soil. A building or structure may become distressed when the fill soil compacts or subsides following completion of construction. When the fill soil consolidates, the building settles. Settlement can lead to foundation cracks, wall cracks, difficulty in the opening of windows or doors. The severity of the fill settlement can also depend on the depth of the fill. The deeper the fill, the greater the capacity for consolidation, and the greater possibility for building movement. Not all buildings constructed on fill soils will settle to the extent of causing damage to the structure. Common problems that lead to fill settlement are the improper placement, or compaction of the fill soils. Fill needs to be compacted to at least 90% during the grading process to meet the minimum building code requirements. If the grader fails to compact the soil properly, there is a greater risk of building settlement. Another factor that may lead to settlement is the use of improper material in the fill. Organic materials or the use of too much rock in the fill can lead to soil settlement.EXPANSIVE SOIL:
In contrast to damage caused by buildings settling or subsiding, damage can also occur when the soil beneath a structure expands or heaves. Another name for expansive soil is clay. Homes built on clay frequently experience problems due to soil movement. Clay soils will expand when they get wet. Clay soils will shrink when they dry out. This cycle of expansion and contraction can wreak havoc on a building foundation system. It is not uncommon for soils to become saturated during a rainy season, or even from frequent watering of the landscape placed around a new home. Dry summers, drought, and water rationing can result in the soil drying out, and shrinking. These cycles of saturation and drying out can cause a foundation to heave, and then shrink, and this cycle can result in damage to the structure. Cracking of pavement, slabs, stucco are all possible symptoms of expansive soil.TRANSITION LOT:
A transition lot is perhaps the most susceptible to damage from soil movement. A transition lot occurs when only part of the lot contains fill, and the rest of lot is on native ground. In the area where a transition from fill to cut or native soil occurs, it is not unusual to experience building distress. This can occur because the fill soil and the native soil respond differently to the introduction of water, and other mechanisms. When the fill side expands or contracts at a rate different than the native soil side, damage can result. Cracking of walls, floors, slabs, and driveways or other flatwork are all indications of movement of the underlying soils. These problems should be evaluated immediately to determine the cause of the problem, and the extent to which these problems will get worse in the future. 

What Are Expansive Soils?

Expansive soils are soils that expand when water is added, and will shrink when they dry out. Expansive soils are really another name for "clay" soils. The continuous change in volume of the soils can cause significant damage to a home or other building, in addition to harming flatwork, pools, pipes, roads, etc. The primary geographic areas that are affected by expansive soils are in the western United Stated, most nobably California, Arizona, and Arizona.


Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

FindLaw Network